Laughter From the Hereafter @ AMUSEum
Tom Finnigan • Writer • Comic
Comedy Writer Extraordinaire!
by Don Stevens • Comedy Club Diaries • ©2000
Tom Finnigan was a fairly mediocre comedian. It wasn’t his material. He just didn’t have a lot of stage presence. Cantu knew Finnigan was out of work and had a family to support, so he gave Finnigan a job as the bartender. Which at the Zoo was no big deal, because we only had a beer and wine license, so the hardest thing you might have to do in a night was install a new cask of draft beer.
But Finnigan is absolutely the best comedy writer ever to come out of San Francisco. He soon was writing for tons of comics, because the word got out, if you needed material, call Finnigan. Or let me put it another way. On a whim, he sent two pages of his material to the Tonight Show when Carson was still there, and got hired. So he went from being paid $5 an hour to making $200,000 a year.
Now that is a career leap. Finnigan wrote one of my favorite lines that I heard during my years in comedy: “I was talking to my parents, and they told me my grandmother is upset because she found out I’m doing stand-up comedy. You see, my grandmother had a horrible experience with comedians… she was sexually assaulted by the Three Stooges. A senseless crime. They dragged her in an alley and… threw pies up her dress. To this day, she wakes up in the middle of the night screaming, ‘Woob woob woob woob!’”
Anyway, after we closed the Zoo at 2:00 in the morning, to unwind we’d often go to the only restaurant open nearby, the Sugarplum on California Street, which really was just a glorified Dennys. Cantu says that night it was me, him, Finnigan, and Warren Spottswood; I seem to remember Karen Warner being there, which means I’m probably wrong; I’m almost always wrong. At another table was a group of comics. Barry Sobel, Al Clethan, Jeremy Kramer are the ones I remember, maybe Stephen Pearl too.
Our table was writers. Writers couldn’t stand to be around comedians. (Karen Warner wrote something like, and wrote it much better than I’m going to remember it, “Being a comedy writer means you write brilliant things for comics who can always remember them but can never remember to pay you.”) But writers can have a conversation, it could flow, it wouldn’t get interrupted. (Michael Robertson at the Chronicle wrote about driving with a bunch of us comedy writers and said, “The surprising thing is that they were polite. They didn’t try to one-up each other. They didn’t make fun of each other.”
That’s because we were writers, not comedians. You cannot have a conversation with a comedian.
So our table was laughing, but because we were having a conversation, and the humor kept building with each story that flowed from the last one. The comics at the other table were laughing, because they were throwing food at each other. Each to his own method of entertainment.
One last note about Finnigan. While he was writing for Carson, he told me, “I used to love writing jokes. But now I have to do it everyday, under pressure and deadline. Writing jokes isn’t fun for me anymore.” He also told me, “The editors reject a lot of the stuff I do, but what they do accept, if 25% of those things I write for Carson’s monologue works, I’m satisfied.”
That’s the brutal reality of comedy. If you can succeed 25% of the time – which would mean you’d be fired on any other job – you feel a sense of accomplishment.
Carnac insights lead to first gig
The best writer I’ve ever read… if Michael Pailin and Jonathan Winters had a baby, which I heard might be true. That’s how I’d describe his brain. His very beginning was one night partying with friends. Carson was on the TV and he started doing Carnac. They say he guessed so many punch lines Carson delivered they accused him of seeing the episode before. After he convinced them he really guessed the Carnac jokes they convinced him to find a place to do comedy. So he found this big bar and told the owner he had one hour of material, when he actually had nothing. So he sat down and wrote jokes in the style of Woody Allen because that was his favorite writer. Many years later I found a cassette of his first performance and the jokes were amazing.
The only problem was this first gig was New Year’s Eve, so on the tapes you hear the crowd talking and yelling and other drunk noises. But in the middle of all the commotion, you can hear a few people that were listening… and in stitches. You could hear one lady laughing louder than the drunk crowd. He would later tell me that after his first joke he had two tables in front of the stage laughing and a hundred New Year’s drunks which is what I like to call ‘Rookies’. So he said he sat down on the end of the stage and performed to the two tables laughing. It was probably 1 year after his first performance we headed to San Francisco to give comedy a shot ~Joe
Zoo Tending

Just Beer and Wine
How hard can it be to work in a beer and wine club? And yet Finnigan was the WORST bartender in the history of the 'Zoo'. He constantly kept having drinks returned. People would ask for red wine and he would serve white wine. They would ask for white and he would give them beer. His mind just wasn't in it. But he had a wife and two kids and I couldn't bring myself to fire him. No one was more happy than me when he got hired by the Tonight Show. ~ John Cantu
Difference Between

Writers & Editors
Finnigan told me once when he first went to Hollywood to write for the Tonight Show about a week a half went by and he hadn't gotten one line on the air. Ray Siller, the head writer came to him and said, "Hey, Tom we're paying you a lot of money and you're really not producing much." Finnigan, had been turning in twelve to fifteen lines daily and said, "Ray, I'm sorry but I'm giving you my best lines." Siller, said "No, Tom, don't give me your best lines each day. Give me fifty lines each day. I will pick the best." ~Don Stevens
Material Needs

Aren't just for Laughs
Comedy teachers Finnigan, Giles and Cantu ham it up onstage at Holy City Zoo • San Francisco Chronicle • Michael Robertson • January 27, 1984
His Showcase

Something big for Petaluma
Pessimistic, Cynical, Realistic

N.Y. Comedians' Night
From his beginnings in Brooklyn, isolating for years in his basement, drinking cough syrup, listening to Bob Newhart and Jonathan Winters records, to being drafted to go to Vietnam. Waiting to be shipped out, he came down with rheumatic fever, which got him out of fighting in Vietnam. Instead he ended up stationed in Lancaster (Mojave Desert area) with a cush job as a desk clerk. He later found out that everyone from his neighborhood in Brooklyn, his would-be platoon, died over there. ~Joe
Gag Writers
A gaggle of comics gather outside the Zoo on Clement Street

Deliver a Lesson
• San Ramon Valley Herald • Dana E. Warsop • May 1, 1984
Finnigan was quietly sarcastic…
Bryan's version
My brother, was pretty active as a stand up during this time as well. He was underage for the clubs (14) but dad would get him stage time at The Zoo and the Other Cafe. (He had to wait outside until his name was called.) I remember one time Evening Magazine / PM Magazine coming out to our house in the Sunset District to film a segment on my brother. He was a good stand up, too. The most famous story in my family was the night my dad put Joe on the open mic list at the zoo and then saw Robin (Williams) drop in to do a set. Once my dad saw Robin take the stage he took my brother off of the list and told him,”You don’t want to follow Robin.” “Why not?” Joe said. They went back and forth; my dad trying to explain to him that it’s not a good idea to follow Robin, and my brother insisting that he get some stage time. Dad gave in, and with a sigh (I imagine), put Joe’s name back on the list.
Joe went up after Robin, did his set, and destroyed. Dad said the room went crazy. Robin called Joe backstage to congratulate him on his set and to say, “You’re playing with the big boys tonight.”
The children of the San Francisco comedy scene was a pretty small circle; me, my brother, Connor Pritchard, Zack Williams…Charlie Giglia was an infant. ~Bryan
Joe's version
I did stand up in SF in the 80s when I was 14yrs old, so I went around to clubs with him too. It was a blast. I did a show at The Other Cafe with Jeremy Kramer, billed as “The Youngest Working Comic”. Robin Williams showed up (recently hired for Mork and Mindy and the hottest comic in SF, maybe the world) He just happened to show up when I was supposed to go on. Officially bumped, he went up, my dad freaked out because he didn’t want me to bomb going on after Robin. I told him I didn’t care, I wanted to go on and he reluctantly agreed. I did 15 minutes and killed. After I did my set I went backstage and there was Robin playing the saxophone. It was just me and him, and after about 10 miutes, he stopped playing, put the sax down, looked at me and said “I watched your act and you did really good because you’re playing with the big boys tonight”. Then he started playing again.
~Joe
Magic

Beans
I truly believe my dad was magic. He’s the kind of guy that can guess how many jelly beans are in the big glass jar. Not only would he guess the number, he acted like he knew and expected to win. He once told me he wrote down a list of goals, one being to write for the Carson show by a certain age…if he didn’t get it by then, he would just get a real job. He got the show, the exact year he wrote down. ~Joe
Jokes

from a savant
I wish more people knew he was a comedy savant born to write cartoonish ideas. One joke in his act: I went to Catholic school and the nuns were tough. I remember my first nun “Sister Lefty”. She had a black leather habit with a crucifix rolled up in her sleeve. On her arm she had a tattoo of John the Baptist. She could make a muscle and make his head roll off. ~Joe
working together
Side by Side
He drug me around to every writing job he ever had, except for the Tonight Show and whenever he had to travel. I couldn’t come with to write on the show “Hee-Haw” I wrote on the David Brenner Show with him when he was Brenner's head writer . ~Joe
Breaking News

Busted on his Behalf
I went to watch a Tonight Show taping with my dad and we watched from the camera well. At the exact time Carson said in his monologue. “Ladies snd gentlemen I have some breaking news, dad accidentally knock over a wooden box and Carson said “and there it is.” I turned around, dad was gone, leaving me the most likely suspect for knocking over the box. Carson was so moody, dad knew he could have been fired for something like that. ~Joe
Best Jokes Unleashed

Worst Jokes Chosen
We wrote everything from Byron Allen's Unleashed for $25 a joke. We would watch Byron’s monologue, competing to find out if any of our jokes made it. We wrote a bunch of good jokes and he just wouldn’t pick any of those, so we decided we were gonna write the worst jokes we could think of… and started getting jokes on air, left and right. ~Joe
Sherman Hemsley

Pitch
We wrote for Sherman Hemsley (George Jefferson). He was doing an off-Broadway show with dancing, singing and jokes in NY, with hopes of taking it to Vegas. The night before we were supposed to meet with Sherman and his manager to read them all the jokes, my dad got very ill and told me that I was gonna have to go on my own to submit our jokes. I was probably 19yrs old and never did anything like that before¬ and scared to death. I went to lunch, told them our jokes, and they loved them. I was so confident, I told them a joke of mine that dad rejected. I figured since he made me take this meeting, I’m gonna submit it. The Joke: "I think I might have a gambling problem, last night I lost the car in a poker game, man that lady at Avis was pissed."
OK, maybe he was right it’s kinda hackey. LOL . ~Joe
Baseballs
to be Autographed
In 1986-87 we lived in New York. Dad was hired on as head writer for a late night talk show called, "Nightlife" with David Brenner. The show was produced by Motown Productions, a subsidiary of the Motown record label. Which meant the show had access to a lot of heavy hitting musical talent; the band leader was Billy Preston. One time Keith Hernandez was scheduled to appear on the show and dad wanted me and my brother to have autographs. So he bought a couple of baseballs to have Keith sign for us. Keith had to cancel at the last minute so the show was now hours away from air without a guest. (The show was only 30 mins long) As I remember the story dad told, Billy Preston said "I think Eric is in town. I'll see if he can stop by and do a set." He was referencing Eric Clapton, who was in town and did drop by to do a few numbers with Billy Preston and the Band. ~Bryan
all players

in the field
So now dad had baseballs ready to be autographed and no Keith Hernandez. He went ahead and had (a slightly confused) Eric Clapton sign a couple of baseballs for me and my brother. This started a running joke between dad and I. We both knew that I had/have no interest in sports but enjoyed the novelty of having a non-sports celebrity's autograph on a baseball. Dad kept the joke going and continued to collect signatures on baseballs of MY heros.....and Chevy Chase. Autographs in photos: Eric Clapton, Steve Martin, Chevy Chase, Dick Smothers and Tommy Smothers. I still have them all encased in my office. My brother used his to play baseball... ~Bryan
On Deck circle

swinging the heavy bat
We returned to California after "Nightlife" with David Brenner was canceled and I went on a trip to LA with dad as he connected with friends and industry people. This would have been around 1988 - 1989. While in town we visited the home of "Tonight Show" writer Bob Dolan Smith, who was an avid baseball fan and collected sports related memorabilia. In his collection he had uniforms, hats, a baseball bat, and other props he found on "the lot" after "some baseball" movie finished filming; all of which was scheduled for the trash. (back when nobody thought to collect movie epherma.) Bob rushed in and saved all the pieces he could, not ever knowing what movie the props were from. To Bob it was all "old timey" baseball stuff and it caught his eye. Turns out it was from "The Natural" starring Robert Redford. At the time of our LA visit he/we then knew the significance of the collection and stood in awe of his find. After a full afternoon of listening to Dad and Bob chat and a quick trip to his rooftop to show us that he has a view of the Psycho house on the Universal Lot, Bob gifted me a few pieces from his collection. Which included the "Wonderboy" bat from the movie, which I still have to this day. ATTN: Collection nerds. It is not screen matched and the lightning bolt doesn't come close to what is on the screen. But it did come from the set. The bat's use in the filming process is still a mystery.
Hired

Fired, Rehired
The story of Tom getting the Tonight Show, losing the Tonight Show, then getting re-hired by Carson personally will be told someday. He was the only writer ever hired on the show without a Harvard or Yale degree. He had a high school GED equivalency and was self taught… and one of the smartest people I’ve ever known.
Dad sitting behind Johnny’s desk on the set during the final days of Johnny’s tenure. No story other than Dad wanting to take the opportunity for a photo before the final show. (circa 92)
We're Going to

Disneyland!
The day he got fired from the Tonight Show, he took us to Disneyland, like he won the Super Bowl. We drove us there in a brown car he was renting from the Ugly Duckling Rent-a-Car place. (He used to drive that piece of shit on the NBC lot and park next to Ed McMahon's Rolls Royce). We park at Disneyland and he hides 3K in the trunk of the car. When we came back, the money is gone. He just lost his job on Carson, now he probably lost all the money we had left. I never remember him even getting upset about it. I’m telling you, he didn’t care about money or being some kind of famous, he just knew things would fall into place. ~Joe
Catering

Fast Food
Near the end, I visited him every day in the hospital… and made him laugh. Day after day, I snuck fast food, soda and candy bars past the nurses station. Told him I was starting a catering business for people on their death beds called “Last Bites”. He lost it and started coughing and laughing. The nurse came in to ask what I had done to him, also busted him with a hoagie and a Pepsi. . ~Joe
599 Monologues & interim Staff Writing
Star of his own sketch
In the last year of the The Tonight Show, Tom wrote a sketch called Misery Bingo, with alot of moving parts, including himself. The home and studio audience could participate, by matching their bingo cards with the random numbers targeted by Johnny himself. The categories used to prep the OUCH cards were personalized with questions like: “The approximate age in months of that thing in the back of your refrigerator that looks like Willie Nelson with a stem”, “The number of things you have that droop, that used to point.”, “How times have you stepped on something while barefo0t and uttered a word that Billy Graham has never heard.”, ” The number of times in your childhood you entered a public restroom and accidentally stepped into a stall that already had feet.”
Memories Shared
Determined to get on the Carson writing team…
The Zoo was recommended to me by Tom Finnigan, a fan of my radio show in Red Bluff in NorCal, “1520 on your dial, the big voice of Tehama County!” Tom and I improvised some comedy shtick on the show and I videotaped us monkeying around in the studio. Finnegan was determined to get on the Carson writing team and split Red Bluff for Hollywood. Tom did wangle a writing slot on Carson and encouraged me to follow the path he had taken. Sadly, there was no slot in the writers’ room to pull me in. Finnigan suggested I head to San Francisco, hit the Holy City Zoo, buttonhole John Cantu to get stage time… John looked at me like just another wannabe standup, and his brow furrowed until I mentioned Finnigan, and he warmed a bit. ~Marty Higgins
@ The Holy City Zoo…
John Cantu arranged for Tom Finnigan, Mike Bizarro (Iapoce), and myself to do a show on the Marina Green. It was some sort of national event – “A Pacific Ha!” – put on by a woman who was a conceptual artist. This was just part of the whole event where everyone in America was supposed to have a good laugh. Cantu asked the three of us to do the show because we always worked “clean.” Said John, “That’s important, because there may be a few children in the audience.”
A few children. When we arrived at the Green (it was early morning, no less), we found the audience consisted of about 200 children and a few adults watching them. And by children I mean elementary school age kids. Now, it’s not like Mike, Tom, or I had any material for the nap-time crowd, but we were committed. Asking us who wanted to go first, Mike and Tom bravely took one step back and said, “Giles!” ~ Paul Giles
Marin 11 taping
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.
Saw Tom on Broadway…
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.
Contributing your memories to other's pages is much appreciated
- The Memorial Story form will whisk your story to Google to store it once you click the Submit button.
- If there is a member of the community we have left out, please alert AMUSEum about the omission.
As a structural starting point,…
This section will disappear when your page goes LIVE… once you’re finished filling in the gaps and satisfied with the look and feel of your ‘wing’ of AMUSEum.
- • • • • • •
- Words
- Images
- Video
- Links
I included the stories you texted me. Always room for more and open to your edits as needed














